| |
 |
|
Depression
Relevance and Phenomenology In the industrialized world, almost 10% of the population is
affected by depression every year. By the year 2020 the World Health
Organization estimates that depression will rank second, after heart
disease, as the leading cause of disability (at present it is in fifth
place).
Depression generates a significant economic burden and
untold human suffering not only on the individuals affected by it, but
also for those around them, sometimes posing a threat to the stability of
the family, workplace, friendships and life itself. Much of this suffering
is unjustified in light of current treatment options and
prospects.
Depression is a far more complex disorder than the
condition once defined simply as melancholy, “the blues” or “having a
nervous breakdown”.
A depressed mood (or simply a sad mood), which represents
the emotional affective side of this disorder, represents only one aspect
of a condition that is probably triggered by malfunctions in several areas
of the brain that produce effects on a number of different mental and
physical functions (Cassano, 2003).
A great deal of interest has been aroused by recent
evidence to the effect that mental and physical stimuli can actually
change the course, severity and duration of depression, with or without
concomitant pharmacological treatment. Such findings open up promising
prospects for alternative forms of treatment, as an alternative to the
traditional approach which is based largely on the use of antidepressants
associated with psychotherapy.
The treatment regimen proposed here is very much in line
with this trend, which is gaining currency among psychiatrists who
advocate a biological approach to mental disorders.
Depression is characterized by a low mood accompanied by a
series of other mental and physical symptoms such as an overall decline in
energy levels together with listlessness, exhaustion, inability to sustain
the slightest physical effort, generalized lack of initiative and purpose
in mental and physical pursuits, frequent desire for rest and isolation,
low self-esteem, a pessimistic outlook on family, work, social environment
and finances, right down to a catastrophic outlook that may lead to
thoughts of self-injury (suicide).
Sleep disorders (difficulty falling asleep, interrupted
sleep, early morning awakenings, diurnal drowsiness) are often also
present, and sometimes appear long before the onset of other symptoms,
along with restlessness and aggressive behavior (including irritability
and explosive reactions).
Phobic, obsessive and persecutory thinking may be present.
People with depression may interpret the attitudes of others as being
inspired by or oriented towards negative actions or criticism towards
them. However, the overall listlessness that dominates the symptoms causes
an inability to react and often the result is an even more accentuated
negative outlook and overall pessimism regarding the surrounding social
environment.
Hypochondria and pathophobia are also a frequent finding,
resulting from depressive people continuously and obsessively examining
themselves as if “under a magnifying lens” or “under the microscope”, both
physically and behaviorally, in an attitude also known as “rumination”.
This relentless monitoring and “dissection” of themselves leads to
over-emphasizing even the minutest imperfection or disorder, blowing it
out of all proportion, and charging it emotionally to the extent that it
may actually fuel suspicions of diseases of every kind, which a
pessimistic catastrophic outlook will interpret as seriously health- and
life-threatening.
On the affective level, this condition may initially cause
further pain and accentuate the morbid mood states and anxiety that often
accompany depression. But if the depressive condition worsens, then
thoughts of a serious or even fatal disease may be tolerated without
excessive preoccupation, especially when suicidal thoughts
emerge.
The turning of the depressed individual’s attention onto
himself eventually leads to a complete withdrawal and alienation from the
outside world, in a process that may involve people who are very close,
such as family members or caregivers and friends; the individual sometimes
develops progressive dislike and disinterest for them.
In rare cases, persecutory delusions may lead to fearing
conspiracies and plots against the individual, even on the part of people
who support them and are closest to them; in this case thoughts of
aggression and revenge may ensue. However, lack of purposefulness and
confidence in their own resources and abilities (loss of self-esteem)
frequently lead depressed people to give up such attitudes and become
remissive, if anything developing more marked morbid moods and delusional
thinking.
Common physical complaints include: marked tiredness and
an inability to embark on any physical or mental activity or initiative
(i.e. refusing to leave the house, get out of bed or up from an armchair,
tendency to stay in the dark without opening windows or shutters) and the
onset or worsening of muscle pain, joint pain (rheumatism), back pain,
“cervical” pain and headache. In many cases the depressed person also
complains of pain involving the mouth or face (neuralgia, and a stinging
or tingling sensation in the cheeks or tongue), or even toothache
(sometimes mimicking dental decay and gum disease).
The depressed individual may become obsessed with his
mouth and teeth due to actual occlusive disorders (abnormal contact
between the upper and lower teeth) which, due to oversensitivity
(hyperalgesia/hyperesthesia) and paying excess attention to the mouth and
face (hypervigilance) may cause latent preclinical conditions to become
symptomatic.
Because the teeth, mouth and face are of particular
importance in conceiving every person’s ego, depressed people may project
pain or pathological attention on to them, giving rise to the following
conditions:
- psychogenic pain without an underlying disease due to
an altered pain threshold or to hypervigilance;
- aggravation of pain caused by existing disorders
(dental, periodontal, arthritic or muscular);
- projection of pain from anatomically and functionally
neighboring areas to the face (cervical region, maxillary sinuses,
etc.);
- complaints of psychogenic (imaginary) pain associated
with hysteria
A rather frequent and somewhat disturbing
symptom that may result from the pharmacological treatment of depression
is tremors. Tremors may affect the upper and lower limbs (restless
legs syndrome), arousing serious concerns over neurological disorders such
as Parkinson’s disease and syndrome. Other neuro-degenerative diseases
that can seriously impair the ability to work may be preceded or
accompanied by depression (link: headache).
In some cases, tremor affecting the teeth may present as
mandibular dyskinesia (uncontrolled jaw movements with chattering
of the teeth - oral/oromandibular dyskinesia).
Occlusive disorders are also frequent, with
the person feeling distressed by the way the upper teeth come into contact
with the lower ones (the sensation is of “malocclusion”), and consequently
developing abnormal habits (parafunctions) like bruxism (grinding the
teeth) when awake by the day, or during sleep (link: craniomandibular
disorders).
For these individuals the clinical process is particularly
tiring and often fruitless: the diagnosis may be difficult to make both
specifically (malocclusive disease) and generally (depressive syndrome and
somatization); moreover the treatment plan may be difficult to implement
due to the poor cooperation of the patient who minimizes or rejects the
possible psycho-somatic origin of the problem.
Tremors may occasionally become generalized, especially
during drug treatment, and become associated with another frequent symptom
represented by loss of balance and abnormal posture , ranging from simple
instability to the inability to stand up or walk normally. Dizziness may
be common, sometimes leading to fainting (lipothymia) when getting up from
the seated or lying position. It may be difficult to walk a short straight
line without wobbling.
These disorders may be well controlled right up to
complete remission through a suitable regimen of physical
activity.
If left untreated, these disorders often understandably
accentuate the anxieties and concerns felt by the person about his health,
further limiting his willingness and desire for regular working, social
and recreational activity.
The depressed individual’s general mental and physical
inertia is often mistakenly interpreted by those nearest to him, including
family and friends, as signs of laziness or lack of will power.
Consequently, they may develop ambivalent feelings of compassion and
annoyance, frequently fuelled by a well meaning resolve to prod and
stimulate the depressed individual who is considered to be failing to
react to his condition.
Guilt feelings and deep frustration can thus be brought on
in the depressed person, who is often genuinely aware of his inertia, and
wants to react, but at the same time is totally unable to. A common
mistake committed by those who live alongside people who are depressed is
to constantly stigmatize their inertia, attributing it to lack of will
power and a weak character, and relentlessly urging them to muster their
resources, react to their condition, and activate an initiative
(purposefulness and ideation) that is inconsistent or entirely
absent.
The blame is therefore put on the depressed person if it
proves to be impossible to involve him in initiatives and activities that
he was previously interested in.
On the contrary, understanding and sympathy are necessary,
along with reassurances that his real inability to undertake any kind of
action or initiative is transient. He must be encouraged to choose
whatever activities he may like or be willing to perform, even if he is
not particularly enthusiastic or interested in them, provided they do not
overly strain his condition but rather demand commitment and attention
(distracting him from his “rumination”) even without satisfaction or
particular enjoyment.
These activities serve to keep the depressed person’s
“social communication” channels open and represent a vital “anchor” to
prevent isolation.
The atmosphere of incomprehension and gradual
marginalization that depressed people develop towards family members,
aggravated by persecutory thinking (betrayal, disinterest,
incomprehension, irritation, hostility) lead them towards latent or
manifest conflicts with their spouse or partner, who is called upon to
provide support and encouragement – a weighty task that is, however,
essential for the recovery of the depressed person’s health.
Because of their privileged affective position, spouses
and partners may contribute significantly towards preventing the condition
from spiraling towards self-injurious behavior (suicide).
Sensory disorders (dysperceptions) and feelings that may
not be so severe as to be disabling but may still aggravate the already
altered perceptions that many depressed people have of themselves, are
represented by cenesthesic abnormalities, generally involving smell and
taste, and sometimes, though rarely, touch and sight.
Vision may be altered due to an apparent or actual
decrease in visual acuity, which may cause anxiety or obsessive behavior.
Impaired gustatory and olfactory function can be explained by the well
known dominance of the hypothalamus, the brain center that is of primary
importance in human emotional reaction. Such changes largely consist in
altered perceptions of smells or tastes, and the recurring and unjustified
perception of specific smells that may be pleasant, or so unpleasant as to
become more intolerable than is generally the case under normal
conditions.
These changes in taste may lead the depressed individual
towards unusual eating patterns or behavior during crisis situations.
There is often a craving for sweets, and a desire for food or beverages
never previously enjoyed, or a refusal of old favorites.
Depressed people may seek specific psychoactive substances
and become addicted to them if they are felt to ease the pain (alcohol,
coffee, tea, drugs). Sometimes once the crisis has subsided, there is a
return to customary eating habits and normal sensory responses, but it is
not unusual for altered taste and smell to persist for prolonged periods,
if not indefinitely.
As a result of altered taste and smell, there may be a
tendency to modify eating habits both in terms of quantity and quality,
with resulting changes in calorie intake. This may lead to weight loss
(anorexia nervosa) or, more frequently due to reduced physical activity,
to sometimes marked weight gain, which may in turn become an even stronger
discouragement from undertaking physical activity.
One characteristics feature of altered tactile cenesthesic
function in depression is intolerance of the cold. Warm baths and showers
are seen as restorative and gratifying. It is reasonable to believe that a
preference for warm environments and a desire to “cover up” is more than a
mere “regressive” mental and physical aspect associated with a generic
yearning for protection. Such behavior may be related to significant
variations in the thermoregulatory system, caused by
neuro-endocrinologically based metabolic changes (the
psycho-neuro-endocrinology of depression).
Indeed, the hormonal profile of the depressed person shows
characteristic variations, albeit of uncertain diagnostic value, such as
elevated cortisol levels, possibly a sign of impaired regulation of
the adrenal-hypothalamus-pituitary/hypothalamus-pituitary-thyroid axes. In
depressed people, sexual desire may weaken considerably to
the point of total impotence (loss of libido and erectile
capacity)
At the cognitive level, depressed individuals display a
series of disorders such as the inability to concentrate, memory flaws,
inability to mentally organize thoughts and plans, with an apparent and
sometimes genuine reduction in information processing and problem solving
skills, often with underlying anxiety.
Impaired intellectual skills may have a major negative
impact on self-esteem and the confidence to tackle with life normally
(study, work, private and social relations), fuelling the downward spiral
towards suicide.
On the emotional plane, the depressed often feel the need
for comfort yet at the same time have negative feelings of mistrust
leading to hostility towards those around them, causing a further
withdrawal into themselves, and the tendency to underestimate or criticize
those offering help.
Types of depression Depressive disorders come in different forms, that can be
defined clinically (i.e. number and type of symptoms) and in terms of the
intensity, frequency and persistence of symptoms.
Dysthymia is a less severe form
of depression. It involves long-term (chronic) symptoms that do not
disable yet prevent the affected person from enjoying a fully satisfying
life. People with dysthymia often also experience episodes of major
depression during their lifetime.
Major depression is
characterized by a combination of symptoms that interfere with the ability
to work, sleep, study, eat and enjoy once-pleasurable family and social
relations.
Disabling episodes can be
isolated and occur only once in the course of a lifetime, or
recurrent, when they are more frequent.
Bipolar disorder (manic
depression) is characterized by periods of depression and euphoria.
Sometimes the mood swings are dramatic and sudden, but most often they are
gradual. During the depressive phase, the individual displays all the
typical signs and symptoms of depression, whilst in the manic phase energy
levels are abnormally high and hyperactivity may appear in different forms
(extreme irritability, restlessness, loquacity and garrulousness with a
tendency to monopolize conversations), along with overly assertive and
overbearing behavior, exaggerated extroversion, increased sexual desire
and activity, excessive generosity and a tendency to underrate risks and
dangers, excessive self-esteem and confidence in one’s own resources,
grandiose notions, narcissism.
There may often be a reduced need for sleep. The
individual may be affected by poor judgment and lack of self-criticism,
and display inappropriate social behavior including exhibitionism.
There is a condition defined as hypomania, in which
only a few of the symptoms of manic episodes are present, or if many are
present, are much attenuated.
In short, the most frequent symptoms of depression
are:
- persistent feelings of sadness/melancholy
- recurrent anxiety, agitation and restlessness
- pessimism, lack of confidence
- feelings of guilt, uselessness
- loss of interest and pleasure in activities that were
once gratifying, hobbies, sex
- loss of energy, fatigue, exhaustion, feelings of
slowing down
- difficulties in concentrating, remembering,
decision-making
- altered sleep patterns (insomnia or hypersomnia,
early-morning awakening, difficulty falling asleep, interrupted
sleep
- increased or decreased appetite, generally with weight
gain
- negative thoughts (death and disease) and
self-injurious behavior (suicide)
- short-temperedness and irritability
- appearance or worsening of physical symptoms that often
fail to respond to treatment such as headaches, oro-mandibular
dysfunctions, digestive disorders (indigestion, constipation), and
chronic somatic pain (often musculoskeletal or rheumatic, involving the
back and neck)
The most common symptoms of mania:
- abnormal loquacity
- excessive irritability
- reduced need for sleep
- grandiose notions
- profligacy
- exaggerated self-esteem and confidence in one’s own
possibilities, narcissism
- under-estimation of risks and dangers
- lack of self-criticism
- inappropriate social behavior.
Causes of depression
Certain types of depression may run in families, suggesting a
constitutional (genetic) predisposition.
Bipolar disorder and manic depressive syndrome may present
with the same characteristics, for which a specific genetic profile has in
fact been identified.
However, it is not true that persons displaying a genetic
vulnerability to the disease will necessarily develop it. A series of
concomitant factors (environmental, etc.) are responsible for its
emergence and these depend primarily on external environmental causes
(i.e. stresses at home, work or school etc.).
People with low self-esteem and a pessimistic personality
who display vulnerability to stress are particularly prone to depressive
illness and much of their early life may have been influenced by a mild
(preclinical) form of depression.
It has recently been demonstrated that several organic
diseases (such as stroke, heart attacks, cancer, Parkinson’s disease,
endocrine disorders) can give rise to depressive disorder, which
negatively impacts the course, duration and response to treatment of the
underlying disease (through refusal of treatment, apathy and non-compliant
behavior).
The loss of loved ones, difficult social relations (in
particular in the home and workplace), financial difficulties, stressful
life events including those most strongly desired like the birth of a
child, or sudden changes in habits and lifestyles can all trigger a
depressive episode. It is likely that the cause of depressive disorder
lies in the interaction of genetic, psycho-social and environmental
factors.
Later, even minor stressful events may trigger depressive
episodes.
Differences between the sexes and among different age
groups Women are affected by depression about twice as often as
men. Hormonal factors may contribute to the increased rate of
depression in women, particularly those associated with the menstrual
cycle (PMS – pre-menstrual syndrome), pregnancy, the post-partum period
and menopause.
Women also frequently face greater responsibilities than
men both at work and at home (caring for children, elderly parents,
housework and a career).
Post-partum depression (“the baby blues”) is particularly
threatening, in that hormonal and physical changes occur together with the
added responsibility of a new baby. Treatment of this condition requires
the involvement of a sensitive physician and the emotional support of the
family, amongst others.
Depression in men presents less frequently than in
women, but may be more severe, leading to a four times higher rate of
suicide among men, though women tend to display more “suicidal
tendencies”.
Suicide occurs most frequently in the elderly (peaking
between the ages of 70 and 85). The mental and physical involvement seems
to be more intense in men, also because serious cardiovascular problems
such as heart disease and stroke appear most frequently in this age
group.
Depression in men may be masked by alcohol or drugs, or by
behavior like anger, irritability, discouragement, and overwork. Men are
often less willing to seek help and support, so it may be difficult to
recognize and treat depression.
Some people argue that the elderly frequently
display depressive symptoms because of their shorter life expectancy and
less satisfying quality of life. This belief is biased and mistaken in
most cases, since older people are generally satisfied with their lives;
today, the elderly can look forward to a longer, happier and more
comfortable life than in days gone by.
However, unless diagnosed and treated appropriately,
depression may cause unwarranted suffering for the elderly person, the
family and caregivers. Often the symptoms described are physical, since
older people tend to be reluctant to discuss feelings of hopelessness,
sadness, loss of interest in activities that were once pleasurable, or
grief after the loss of a loved one.
It is crucial to recognize this attitude in order to
correctly diagnose depression in the elderly. Once identified, the older
person will benefit from the usual treatment options for depression based
on medication, brief psychotherapy (“talk therapy”) or
cognitive/behavioral therapy. Psychotherapy can be a viable alternative
when medication cannot or will not be taken (for example, because of
slower drug washout and turnover rates, impaired kidney and liver
function, a more vulnerable nervous system, and so on).
Psychotherapy has proven to be effective in providing
psychological support in particularly difficult times such as terminal
disease, advanced age and disability.
The concept of depression in children as a specific
pathology has only developed relatively recently (in the 1980s). The
depressed child may pretend to be sick, refuse to go to school, cling to a
parent, or fret over the prospect of a parent falling ill or
dying.
Older children may sulk, fall back at school, be negative,
cranky, and feel misunderstood. Since normal behaviors change from one
childhood stage to the next, it may be difficult to understand whether a
child is genuinely depressed or simply going through a difficult phase in
normal development.
Occasionally the parents are concerned about changes in
the child’s behavior, or a teacher may mention to the parents that the
child is having problems at school, or performing below his usual
standards.
The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH / Bethesda),
a highly distinguished American body, recommends considering the use of
medications for treating childhood depression in selected cases
(NIMH-supported Research Units on Pediatric Psychopharmacology-RUPPs).
Despite the fact that RUPPs studies advocate the use of
drugs in the treatment of depressed children, under the supervision of the
child’s doctor, there is growing opposition to this recommendation.
Recently, controlled trials have generated numerous reservations on the
safety of medications in children, and even the latest generation SSRIs
appear to cause serious adverse effects on the child’s mental and physical
development.
Diagnosis and treatment of depression
Diagnosis The first
step in treating depression is a complete physical examination with lab
tests.
Many disease states can co-exist with or simulate
depression, including iatrogenic conditions (i.e. disorders due to the
undesirable side effects of drug treatments, including antidepressants and
mood altering medications).
Only when the physical causes have been ruled out should a
psychological problem – primary depressive disease – be suspected.
The diagnostic evaluation must include:
- patient history, to
- identify the nature, frequency and duration of
symptoms
- evaluate previous clinical conditions (i.e.
psychiatric disease or suggestive signs and symptoms)
- investigate any conditions previously diagnosed and
treated
- probe and assess possible family history of
depression or preclinical states
- enquire about the use of alcohol or drugs
- identify thoughts of suicide or death
- evaluate the patient’s mental status, cognitive
functions, and in particular, speech, thought patterns and memory
- examine the affective profile of the patient
(personality);
- an essential neurological examination
- if physical disease is suspected, in specific
cases:
- diagnostic imaging exams (Computerized Tomography/CT,
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance/NMR and Positron Emitting Tomography /
PET)
- blood chemistry (lab tests), (Russel Vickers, IASP,
Sydney, 2005)
Treatment Treatment
choice will generally depend on the results of the preliminary diagnostic
evaluation.
There are a number of conventional treatment options
available that involve the use of antidepressant medications and
psychotherapies (support, cognitive behavioral, etc.). In some milder
forms, psychotherapy alone may produce satisfactory results, while in
moderate to severe cases the use of antidepressants in association with
psychotherapy is generally recommended.
When people fail to respond to conventional treatment, and
particularly if they display suicidal tendencies, or when there is a
contraindication for such treatment, many centers advocate and perform
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), also known as Electro-shock therapy. The
Italian psychiatrist by the name of Cerletti is credited with formulating
this type of treatment.
ECT produces an actual electric shock. Electrodes are
placed at precise locations on the head to deliver short electrical
impulses (30 seconds), which the patient does not consciously experience.
Today ECT treatment is far less traumatic for the patient,
who is first given a muscle relaxant or brief anesthesia; for best
results, several sessions of ECT are usually required at the rate of three
per week, on an in-patient basis. Hospitalization is always recommended
whenever there are suicidal or self-injurious tendencies and the
individual needs to be kept under close observation.
Parenteral (intravenous) medications may be given more
easily to in-patients and hospitalization also facilitates the choice of
an effective treatment protocol, and close monitoring of the
outcome.
Medications
Traditionally, there are three categories of antidepressant
medications: tricyclics, monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) and
selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs).
The latter (chiefly Prozac) are more recent medications
that date to the 1980s. Since they are presumed to be more effective and
produce fewer side effects, the belief has spread among the general
population that depression is a common easily treatable psychosocial
disorder. People tend to regard it as separate from other mental diseases,
and are more willing to take medication even if they were once mistrustful
or hostile towards drug treatments.
The presumed relative harmlessness of SSRIs has also led
to these medications being used on pediatric patients.
However, it is often necessary to try several drugs before
finding the most effective medication for the individual patient.
Sometimes the dose levels have to be increased to be effective. Although
some improvements may appear very quickly, even after a week, it generally
takes at least three or four weeks before the full therapeutic effect can
be observed.
This slow time-to-effect sometimes makes the patient think
the treatment is not working, and ask for it to be replaced, especially if
side effects aggravate the typical symptoms of depression such as feelings
of fatigue, lack of energy and blunting.
Some of the typical side effects of tricyclic
antidepressants may be:
- gastrointestinal – dry mouth, nausea, vomiting,
constipation
- visual – reduced visual acuity, scotoma
- olfactory and auditory – hallucinations or
dysperceptions
- neurological and otoneurologal (impaired concentration,
memory and thinking, drowsiness/lethargy, tremors, loss of balance,
dizziness)
- sexual (loss of sex drive)
- urinary (difficult urination, pollakiuria)
- arthromuscular (joint pain and the appearance or
aggravation of rheumatic and musculoskeletal pain)
Symptoms that are characteristic of SSRI
antidepressants include:
- headache and orofacial pain
- nausea
- restlessness and sleep disorders
- tremors and loss of balance
The onset of side effects such as these without any
appreciable reduction in affective symptoms may worsen the depression and
cause patients to stop taking the medication or to develop an even more
negative view of their condition.
In other cases, if the medication is effective, patients
are often tempted to stop taking it too soon.
Once an improvement has been noticed, the medication must
be taken for at least 4-9 months, to prevent recurrences of the
depression; in any case the decision to discontinue or modify treatment
must be taken by the physician, not the patient.
Antidepressants of any kind can be discontinued only
following a rational dose reduction schedule (called controlled
“wash-out”).
In some cases such as bipolar disorder (manic-depressive
disorder), medication (such as Lithium salts) may need to be maintained
indefinitely.
When taking antidepressants, a number of activities and
habits will be prohibited or restricted. These may include alcohol and
certain medications that may reduce the effectiveness of the
antidepressant, driving the car, and tasks that require precision and
responsibility, due to the risk of synergic effects causing a decline in
alertness and slower, less well controlled mental and physical reflexes
and responses.
Natural therapies (“Herbal therapy”) Several natural remedies involving the use of
herbs have been proposed in the past to treat anxiety and
depression.
Hypericum Perforatum (St John’s
Wort) is used extensively throughout Europe and has recently aroused
interest also in the United States.
The plant, which is a shrub that produced yellow flowers
in the summer, has been used for hundreds of years in folk remedies. St
John’s Wort is the most popular antidepressant currently used in
Germany.
Though the National Institute of Health has conducted
controlled trials sponsored by three NIH branches – the National Institute
of Mental Health, the National Center for Complementary and Alternative
Medicine, and the Office of Dietary Supplements – no evidence exists to
suggest that St. John’s Wort is as effective as some SSRIs (e.g.
Sertraline). In February 2000, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
published a Public Health Advisory, indicating the proven efficacy of
Hypericum Perforatum in modifying the metabolic pathways of a series of
drugs used for treating AIDS, cardiovascular disease, depression, seizures
(epilepsy), certain tumors and rejection of transplants (immunosuppressive
drugs).
These interactions must be taken into serious
consideration by those who prescribe and take these herbal
remedies.
Other popular herbal supplements those efficacy has not
been proven include ginko biloba, ginseng, ephedra and
echinacea.
Psychotherapies Several forms of psychotherapy, including some short-term
(10-20 weeks with interpersonal or cognitive behavioral treatments) can
help people who are depressed.
Talking therapies, together with exercises that can be
performed at home, can be useful in behavioral therapy, helping patients
to gain insight into the possible causes of their condition, and teaching
them to “reprogram” their attitudes and emotional affective reactions
(thinking) towards disturbing thoughts and situations associated with
depression.
Psychodynamic therapies are sometimes used in depression
to analyze and resolve emotional conflicts, though these therapies are
more effective when the symptoms of depression are starting to diminish.
However, the use of medication is generally recommended and, in
non-responders, relapses and under special conditions, ECT may be used
along with or before psychotherapy.
Therapeutic Support Strategies
- behavioral choices
- lifestyle choices
- exercise and physical therapy
Depression brings on negative thoughts and pessimism,
hopelessness, helplessness, worthlessness and a feeling that external help
and care are pointless.
Until the chosen treatment begins to take effect it is
essential to try and break the vicious circle of negative thoughts with a
series of behaviors that should be adopted in all cases, including
situations that are at risk for depression and
recurrences:
Behavioral choices
- set realistic goals in relation to the degree of
depression and assume a reasonable amount of responsibility
- prioritize commitments in terms of their importance and
urgency, and if possible, break tasks down into smaller ones that can be
coped with more easily
- try not to become socially isolated, and seek the
support of reliable people
- participate in activities and initiatives that at least
provide some distraction, if not enjoyment and satisfaction. Look for
activities that might be potentially gratifying (social or church work,
etc.)
- prepare for a gradual improvement, rather than a sudden
change, and accept that cognitive behavioral strategies will be
effective in the long run (use positive thinking and “anchoring”)
- postpone important decisions and commitments until
after the depression has eased (new job, changes in marital status,
etc.)
- if possible, discuss choices and problems with people
who are trusted and emotionally close
- encourage and be open to the help of family and
friends
- rationally opt for positive thoughts and goals
(cognitive behavioral strategies/self-help) and isolate them from the
generally negative views that are typical of depression.
Lifestyle choices
Different lifestyle choices may make a significant
difference:
- a healthy diet and life habits
- avoid prolonged and tiring activities (work, study) and
every day try to do something potentially gratifying
- avoid meals that might cause digestive problems or be
poorly tolerated (excessive amounts of food or alcohol, heavy meals,
substances likely to cause allergies, and so on)
- adopt a regular routine (at home, work, school, meal
times, sleep), seeking to combine the least effort with the greatest
satisfaction
Exercise and physical therapy
Introduce a rational program of exercise and physical therapy,
including:
- a gradual increase in overall physical
activity (exercise), with:
- making less use of cars and elevators
- brisk walks
- jogging alternating with walking
- jogging
- swimming
learning specific techniques for mental and physical
control and relaxation, such as
- autogenous training
- biofeedback
- controlled breathing
- yoga
- reiki
exposure to sunlight or selective artificial light
(light therapy lamps)
cold water showers, baths and swimming
(CWST/ASS)(Veinsteinas, ASSC, Sanremo 2003; Ciancaglini, ASSC, Sanremo,
2005)
Physical therapy and activity for treating stress, anxiety and
depression
The methods described here for undertaking physical
therapy and activity to treat anxiety, depression and other affective
disorders and forms of dependence are the following:
- Chronotherapy (rebalancing biological rhythms)
by means of
- “wake therapy”, i.e. sleep deprivation
- “light therapy”, i.e. treatment involving exposure to
light
(link: www.sltbr.org)
Outdoor physical activity
Cold Water Therapy/CWT
including:
- Cold Water Showering
- Cold Water Swimming
(link: www.smiline/ASSC)
Gentle exercise in water (aquagym) (Cold Water
Exercise/CWE, Yoga)
Intense exercise in water (Cold Water Work
Out/CWWO)(e.g..Tae Bo)
in water at temperatures ranging from 10 to 20 degrees
Celsius (average temperature 15ºC)
Chronotherapy The
International Society of Affective Disorders (ISAD) recently invited a
group of international experts to set up a Committee on Chronoterapeutics.
Based on current scientific evidence, the Committee provided a Consensus
review of the possible role of treatments employing “chronotherapy”, such
as light and wake therapy, in depressive syndromes.
Both of these treatments act on the neurophysiologic and
neuroendocrine systems that regulate sleeping and waking rhythms, and
produce/release psychoactive chemicals (neurotransmitters) involved in
mood fluctuations, affective disorders, anxiety and depression.
According to this distinguished Committee, which has
published the results of its in-depth analysis of the scientific
literature on the subject in highly reputable magazines (Science, issue
303, 2004, Psychological Medicine, issue 35, 2005), chronotherapy (light
and wake therapy) plays a fundamentally important role, in SAD (stress,
anxiety, depression), and could indeed represent a viable alternative to
conventional treatments relying on antidepressants and psychotherapy (e.g.
cognitive behavioral therapy)
The World Health Organization (WHO) recently reported that
in the industrialized world, depression as a disease dramatically
increasing; by 2020 it is expected to become the second most common
illness after cardiovascular disease (heart failure and stroke); today,
depression ranks fifth. This finding stems from a study based on mortality
and Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) (Scientific American, September
2005).
The WHO recommends that the scientific community prove
that such treatments proposed for depression are not only effective and
sustainable (i.e. well tolerated) but also easy to deliver via simple
protocols (Chrisholm, 2004).
The costs associated with prolonged and sometimes lifelong
conventional therapies, in terms of financial expenditure and physical
side effects, represent an evident limitation, at least for a large
percentage of the population.
Therefore, to comply with the recommendations of the World
Health Organization, effective treatment strategies must be found as an
alternative to medication and psychotherapy.
The development of the ideal drug, capable of achieving
effective results with a shorter time to effect than the current 2-3 weeks
on all aspects of depression, with no adverse side effects and at an
affordable cost is unfortunately still on everyone’s wish list, and the
proven efficacy of psychotherapy in association with medication
nevertheless still comes at a very high price.
Various forms of chronotherapy (wake therapy and light
therapy) therefore represent an alternative that demands to be taken into
serious consideration in light both of their proven effectiveness (Berger,
2004; Benedetti, 2004, Martin, 2004;Terman, 2004; Wu, 2004; Cancun,
2004, 2nd Biennial Conference of ISAD / International
Society of Affective Disorders ) and of their relative simplicity and low cost, as recommended by
the WHO.
The interest displayed by official research and science in
treatments such as these as an alternative to conventional medication is
obviously limited by the immense interests surrounding drug therapy for
affective illnesses. However, the opportunity to make a more targeted and
rational use of medication when combined with alternative treatments
should suggest including chronotherapy among currently available remedies,
at least for those members of the psychiatric community who are more
ethically aware and inclined towards less aggressive treatments for
depression (Wirz-Justice; Science, issue 303, 2004).
Chronotherapy, based on the principles of circadian rhythm
and sleep physiology, offers mental health specialists (psychologists,
psychiatrists, neurologists, patho-physiologists and others) involved in
treating all forms of depression, a series of modalities for monotherapy
or as an adjuvant to conventional medication (multimodal therapy),
combining supplemental light exposure and sleep deprivation with
traditional medication (SSRIs, Lithium salts and other antidepressants
such as MAOIs or tricyclics).
Light Therapy
Controlled
exposure (by duration, intensity and frequency) to selected light sources
has proven to be effective as an elective treatment of SADs (seasonal
affective disorders or seasonal autumn/winter depression).
Recently, it has also been proven that “light therapy” is
likely to be effective also in other illnesses such as:
- major depression (Non Seasonal Disorder/NSD) and forms
of bipolar affective disorders (Yamada, 1995;Lam, 1998)
- premenstrual depression (Lam, 199199)
- post- and ante-partum depression (Epperson,
2004)
- bulimia nervosa (Blonin, 1996;Lam, 1998;Braun,
199199)
- sleep disorders (delayed and advanced sleep phase
syndromes)(Abbot, 2003; Reich, 2004)
- Alzeimer’s disease (Alzeimer dementia, Skjerve,
2004).
The efficacy of “light therapy” in major depression was
supported by Yamada in 1995 and by Benedetti in 2004, and for bipolar
forms by other researchers.
Recent controlled trials appear to prove the efficacy of
“light therapy” when combined with the use of Selective serotonin reuptake
inhibitors (SSRIs), by reducing time to effect, prolonging effect
duration, reducing dose levels and enhancing efficacy (Benedetti,
2004).
According to Kripke (1992), drug latency times drop to
just one week when they are used in association with “light therapy” and
this theory is currently the object of an in-depth analysis
(meta-analysis) (Tunnainen, 2004); Golden, awaiting
publication)
Light therapy is particularly useful because it reduces
time-to-effect to under a week in seasonal depression (autumn-winter or
recurrent depression), when light is provided in the early hours of the
morning (dawn light) for no less than half an hour a day for at least five
consecutive days, with illumination of at least 5000 Lux, Color
Temperature ranging from 4500 to 8000 Kelvin, and a frequency spectrum
(electromagnetic wavelength) over 480 A, at the blue-green end of the
scale.
The only undesirable effects that could be attributed to
Light therapy concerns potential retinal damage (macular degeneration at
frequency spectrum values shorter than 480 A (blue-green
light).
Optimal exposure times could carry some risk when
associated with unusually long treatment cycles.
The recommendation to choose artificial lighting with a
spectrum primarily focused in the green band is not beneficial since these
lamps do not guarantee the same levels of efficacy and require
considerably longer exposure times.
However, it should be noted that there are different types
of depression, each stemming from different causes (i.e. genetic,
environmental, social, stress, etc.).
Spontaneous Internal Desynchronization may be one cause
(or a concomitant cause) of some of these depressions. Light Therapy is
particularly effective when used to treat seasonal depression (Seasonal
Affective Disorder/SAD).
The use of light with a wavelength longer than 480 nm
(because shorter wavelengths could cause retinal damage) is discouraged by
some authors, who while admitting that blue light is harmful to the
retina, observe that all the evidence points to the fact that the damaging
wavelengths are around 450 nm or less. Recent studies show that blue light
with a wavelength of 464-480 nm has the greatest impact on the human
circadian system (Tosini. Personal Communication, 2005; Brainard et al.,
2001, J. Neuroscience) and for treating specific forms of depression
(Glickman et al., 2005, Biol Psychiatry).
Sleep deprivation In
cases of depression, the speed of the response to sleep deprivation
therapy, whether total or partial deprivation of the second
half of the sleep cycle can be quite amazing.
If this treatment is compared to the two weeks that
represent the minimum response time to conventional medication-based
treatment, the response, which is positive in 60% of cases, is
astonishing, and can begin to appear within hours of initiation (Wu e
Bumey,1990; Liebenlaft e Wehr, 1992; Wirz Justice e Vander Hoofdakker,
199199; Berger, 2003).
The main drawback of “wake therapy” is represented by the
transient nature of the remission with symptoms often reappearing
after even a short compensatory sleep (or nap). It is also
obviously difficult to manage the treatment at the individual clinical
level.
“Wake therapy” is effective even in forms of major
depression. Certain drugs like Lithium and Pindolol (5HT-antagonists)
appear able to enhance and prolong the duration of symptom control exerted
by “wake therapy” and seem to work synergically.
Outdoor physical activities
“Exercise eases symptoms of anxiety and depression” (from
Kristin Vickers Douglas; Mayo Clinic Staff - www.mayoclinic.com/invoke)
Kite flying and depression Kite flying, in particular the use of body drag kites, provides
a remarkable opportunity to experience activities of significant
re-educational value leading to significant mental and physical
re-conditioning.
Kites are flown in the open air, on sunny days with
moderate winds (‘light therapy’), in beautiful locations near beaches or
lakes (wind therapy).
“Body drag” kites can be physically gratifying because it
combines kite flying with only moderately challenging physical exertion,
and is highly satisfying if practiced safely and without
difficulty;
The physical exertion required to fly kites varies
considerably depending on the type of kite used and whether it is used for
fun or exercise (work-outs featuring “body drag”, “kite buggy”, “kite
surfing”).
Kite flying demands solutions to unconventional problems
(unraveling wires, untangling knots, straightening lines). Solving these
problems requires discipline, commitment and attention, but also a level
of skill and dexterity that is entirely within the reach of the depressed
individual.
The concentration associated with kites constitutes a
powerful distraction from the depressed person’s characteristic condition
of self-affliction, isolation and “rumination”.
(link: Kite) (link:
www.alivola.it)
The therapeutical use of SMILINE GAME We recommend SMILINE GAME as an unconventional but
highly engaging therapeutic procedure. (link: SMILINE GAME, in
www.smiline.net and www.joyofliving.net)
Where to find help
It is
essential not to tackle depression alone.
Though the family is a fundamental environment in which to
communicate and share thoughts and feelings, it may not always be the
ideal environment (i.e. conflicts, isolation, fragmentation).
There are people, institutions and groups that can
significantly help depressed individuals to come out of their depression
or at least tolerate it more effectively, and above all to avoid turning
inward towards more negative thoughts of disease and death.
Such resources include:
- the family doctor;
- specialists (psychologists, psychiatrists and
neuro-psychiatrists);
- social workers;
- mental health centers and facilities;
- psychiatric clinics and wards in public and private
hospitals;
- medical and psychiatric societies;
- websites on depression (providing useful links and
addresses). These can easily be found by entering keywords like
“depression/care/support/scientific associations” in search
engines.
Or contact: - www.dbsalliance.org -
www.smiline.net
|
|
|
Author: Riccardo
Ciancaglini
The Author reserves complete
title and full intellectual property rights for articles,
photographs, graphics, audio and video materials. In no event may
users or third parties publish, re-write, sell, distribute, or
broadcast the aforementioned property in any form and by any
medium. | |
You are here: Home-Topics-Depression
Previous Topic: Anxiety Next Topic: Chronic fatigue
|